| |
| | Scientia Scholae, Spring 2005 - Tolkien and Chivalry |
 | | But in his play "The Homecoming of Beorhtnoth Beorhthelm's Son" and its accompanying essay "Ofermod," Tolkien makes the nuancing particularly clear: in fact, like Twain, he makes an explicit critique of chivalry, and does so in part with reference to the nineteenth century, though with a British, rather than American, war in mind. |
 | | Tída criticizes Totta's killing the robber as an illusion of heroism: it was unworthy of Beorhthelm's sword to use it to kill a wretched creature who could have been driven off with a swift kick (we may remember Gandalf lecturing Frodo on the role of pity). |
 | | We are supposed to see a contrast between (on the one hand) the framing elements of Theoden leading the first charge of the Rohirrim and Eomer, his mind cleared, forming his shield wall, and, on the other hand, that which is framed, Eomer's fey, redeless, hasty, headlong charge. |
| www.teamsmedieval.org /scientia_scholae/0505/tolkein.html (2040 words) |
|