
	Where results make sense

Topic: Compatibilism and incompatibilism

In the News (Sat 18 May 13)

EXECUTIVE POWER

Iran

ANALYSIS

Pakistan

Family compact

	Compatibilism and incompatibilism - Psychology Wiki - a Wikia wiki
		Compatibilism and incompatibilism - Psychology Wiki - a Wikia wiki
		Incompatibilism means that the notion of a deterministic universe is completely at odds with the notion that people have a free will.
		Compatibilism, most famously championed by Hume, is a theory that suggests that free will and determinism are in fact compatible.
	psychology.wikia.com /wiki/Compatibilism (1203 words)

	Compatibilism and incompatibilism - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
		There are two central questions about free will - first, whether we actually have it, and second, how it relates to determinism.
		On this account, the notion of free will seems to be just a conceptual confusion we have, that couldn't possibly exist, whether the universe was deterministic or not.
		Compatibilism, also known as soft determinism and most famously championed by Hume, is a theory that threads this needle, suggesting that free will and determinism are in fact compatible.
	en.wikipedia.org /wiki/Compatibilism (969 words)

	Compatibilism and incompatibilism - Encyclopedia.WorldSearch (Site not responding. Last check: 2007-11-02)
		Incompatibilism is the philosophical thesis that if determinism is true, then we don't have free will.
		The denial of incompatibilism is compatibilism; a compatibilist is someone who believes that the truth of determinism does not rule out the existence of free will.
		William James, the American pragmatist philosopher who coined the term "soft determinist" in an influential essay titled The Dilemma of Determinism, held that the importance of the issue of determinism is not one of personal responsibility, but one of hope.
	encyclopedia.worldsearch.com /compatibilism.htm (486 words)

	CAUSAL COMPATIBILISM AND THE EXCLUSION PROBLEM
		Causal compatibilism claims that even though physics is causally closed, and even though mental properties are multiply realizable and hence are not identical to physical causal properties, mental properties are causal properties nonetheless.
		Incompatibilism, on the other hand, entails that such standards are much too lax; under suitable epistemic standards, mental-cause attributions and mentalistic causal explanations are only warranted when one has good evidence that humans instantiate mental properties that are fundamental force-generating properties.
		In particular, compatibilism explains why our ordinary intuitive attributions and presumptions of agency and mental causation, and the accompanying justification standards we rely upon in making such attributions and presumptions, operate in a way that is essentially orthogonal to the question of whether mental properties are fundamental force-generating properties.
	dingo.sbs.arizona.edu /~thorgan/papers/Causal.Compatibilism.htm (6999 words)

	Compatibilism
		According one strand within classical compatibilism, freedom of the sort pertinent to moral evaluation is nothing more than an agent's ability to do what she wishes in the absence of impediments that would otherwise stand in her way.
		Hence, her compatibilism is open to refutation by incompatibilist arguments designed to show that determinism is incompatible with freedom involving alternative possibilities.
		‘Incompatibilism and the Avoidability of Blame.’ Ethics 108: 685-701.
	plato.stanford.edu /entries/compatibilism (15891 words)

	Incompatibilism, Philosophy, Free Essays @ ChuckIII College Resources
		Incompatibilism is the most convincing of the three theories proposed regarding the relationship between free will and determinism.
		The second argument against incompatibilism, to which I will respond, does not assume that reasons and explanations are deterministic but claims that where we have an undetermined action we do not have an agent in control of determining what his action is to be.
		Incompatibilism is the strongest position to hold on the deterministic and free will dilemma.
	www.chuckiii.com /Reports/Philosophy/Incompatibilism.shtml (1844 words)

	Compatibilism and incompatibilism - the free encyclopedia (Site not responding. Last check: 2007-11-02)
		The denial ofincompatibilism is compatibilism; a compatibilist is someone who believes that the truth of determinism does not rule out theexistence of free will.
		William James, the American pragmatist philosopher who coined the term "softdeterminist" in an influential essay titled The Dilemma of Determinism, held that the importance of the issue of determinism is notone of personal responsibility, but one of hope.
		He said that he would not insist upon the name "free will" as a synonym for the role chance plays inhuman actions, simply because he preferred to debate about things, not words.
	www.aaez.biz /?t=Compatibilism_and_incompatibilism (386 words)

	24.00: Freewill III (Site not responding. Last check: 2007-11-02)
		Soft determinism, also known as compatibilism, maintains that determinism is true, but also that determinism is compatible with free will.
		However, the compatibilist and the libertarian agree that we are (sometimes) free; the compatibilist and hard determinist both agree that determinism is true.
		Compatibilism is appealing, but all the forms we've considered seem to have problems.
	www.mit.edu /~shaslang/2400-01/fw3-01.html (1866 words)

	Arguments for Incompatibilism
		Perhaps for this reason: until fairly recently, compatibilism was the received view and it was widely believed that arguments for incompatibilism rest on a modal fallacy or fairly obvious mistake (e.g., the mistake of confusing causation with compulsion, or the mistake of confusing descriptive with prescriptive laws) (Ayer 1954).
		Incompatibilism is the thesis that if determinism is true, then (for that reason) we don't have free will.
		Compatibilism is, minimally, the denial of incompatibilism; the compatibilist is someone who rejects the claim that the truth of determinism would mean that we lack free will.
	plato.stanford.edu /entries/incompatibilism-arguments (9931 words)

	Free will : Routledge Encyclopedia of Philosophy Online
		That is one possible view of what it is to be free; but according to the compatibilists, free will is simply a matter of having genuine options and opportunities for action, and being able to choose between them according to what one wants or thinks best.
		It may be said that dogs and other animals can be free agents, according to this basic account of compatibilism.
		Compatibilism has been refined in many ways, but this gives an idea of its basis.
	www.rep.routledge.com /article/V014SECT1 (1153 words)

	620pixeltable
		Compatibilism is the view that determinism is logically consistent with freedom -- Hobbes and Hume in the 17th and 18th Centuries, and an unbroken line of philosophers down to Frankfurt as often understood and Fischer these days.
		Incompatibilism is the view that determinism is logically inconsistent with freedom -- Bishop Bramhall in 17th Century, and unbroken line down to van Inwagen, Kane and Searle today.
		This is Incompatibilism plus the assertion that we do in fact have the freedom of origination that is incompatible with determinism.
	www.homepages.ucl.ac.uk /~uctytho/dfwHonderichWhatNow.htm (4216 words)

	Untitled Document
		Compatibilism is, roughly, the position that the forms of free will most people clearly have to some degree, such as the ability to deliberate and do as they wish, suffice to meet the requirements of morality and personal life insofar as they are affected by the issue of free will.
		Hence, the term 'compatibilism': the compatibilist insists that free will, moral responsibility, and their concomitant notions are compatible with determinism (or with the absence of libertarian free will).
		Firstly, compatibilism is a widely prevalent view, and hence it is necessary for me to show its inadequacy in order to defend my first radical proposal, the Fundamental Dualism requiring that we be, in a sense, both compatibilists and hard determinists.
	philo.haifa.ac.il /faculty_pages/smilansky/Free_Will_two_radical_proposals.htm (7304 words)

	Are compatibilism and incompatibilism compatible
		Compatibilism, by the contrary, is inconsistent when applied to pop up free will, but consistent if a more conventional version of free will is used.
		Compatibilism is the theory according to which free will is conceivable in a world that evolves according to deterministic rules.
		It should be clear that both compatibilism and incompatibilism are consistent when they are used with the proper notion of free will.
	www.pedro-fonseca.com /en/philosophy/compatibilism.html (1749 words)

	Mormon Philosophy & Theology
		"Is Incompatibilism Intuitive?" (Note that it is a Word file rather than a PDF) It's basically an attack on incompatibilism not from the usual routes, but from the view of intuitions.
		In this paper, we challenge the claim that incompatibilism is intuitive to most laypersons, and we discuss the significance of this challenge to the free will debate.
		We conclude that while our preliminary data suggest that incompatibilism is not as intuitive as incompatibilists have traditionally assumed, more work should be done both to determine what ordinary intuitions about free will and moral responsibility actually are and to understand what role these intuitions should play in the free will debate.
	www.libertypages.com /clark/10445.html (658 words)

	ted6
		A second fundamental proposition of Incompatibilism is that in fact this is an idea of an action both voluntary and originated.
		It is also fundamental to Incompatibilism that the principal philosophical problem of determinism and freedom is that of somehow proving its second and third propositions.
		Compatibilism shares the proposition that we have one settled idea of a free action.
	www.ucl.ac.uk /~uctytho/ted6.htm (3237 words)

	Feeling Good
		Some form of compatibilism, therefore, may be espoused without fear of forfeiting what is necessary for the grounding of morals.
		His argument for compatibilism includes the claim that what matters for moral responsibility is not freedom to choose from an array of undetermined courses of action but the power of reflective self-control.
		He has sought shelter in a compatibilism likely to be rejected by those adhering to the far more interesting theories of determinism and incompatibilism.
	www.leaderu.com /ftissues/ft9601/reviews/robinson.html (2125 words)

	Bath Royal Literary and Scientific Institution
		It is indeed a second assumption of this rapid paper, then, that both Incompatibilism and Compatibilism are false.
		'Compatibilism is the thesis that determinism is consistent with the claim that persons often have moral freedom or freewill.
		Thomas Nagel in an account of determinism and freedom (1986) remarks that he changes his mind about the subject every time he thinks about it, and others may at least be tempted to this carry-on, as I have lately been.
	www.brlsi.org /proceedvol7/lecture200303.htm (6509 words)

	AFTER COMPATIBILISM AND INCOMPATIBILISM
		The real problem of determinism has seemed to be that of accomodating ourselves to the frustration of certain attitudes and practices, at bottom certain desires.
		That is to say that both of Incompatibilism and Compatibilism are false.
		Incompatibilism and Compatibilism are answers to a question with a false presupposition, that we have but one conception of freedom or one important conception, and they themselves presuppose or assert that falsehood.
	www.class.uidaho.edu /inpc/4th-2001/Papers/Honderich.htm (5177 words)

	>-- The Garden of Forking Paths --<: Is Incompatibilism Intuitive? (Site not responding. Last check: 2007-11-02)
		We challenge the claim that incompatibilism is intuitive to most laypersons and discuss the significance of this challenge to the free will debate.
		Kane, for example, states that his incompatibilism should only be taken as incompatibilism about a specific type of moral responsibility (other types may be compatible with determinism).
		Incompatibilism (whether libetarian or skeptic) clearly has more metaphysical theses as necessary conditions for free will than compatibilism does; as such, these conditions need motivation.
	gfp.typepad.com /the_garden_of_forking_pat/2005/03/is_incompatibil.html (6725 words)

	University of Vermont
		At the same time I do not want to disavow incompatibilism, but rather to defend a version in which the pivotal explanatory role is assigned to features of the causal history of the action, and not to the availability of alternative possibilities.
		Thus the issue for leeway incompatibilism (and leeway compatibilism as well) is whether alternative possibilities are relevant per se -- qua alternative possibilities -- to explaining an agent's moral responsibility for an action.
		Suppose that a Frankfurt-style example is proposed in which it turns out that the actual causal history might well be deterministic, but the determinism is not of a sort that is responsibility-undermining given compatibilist intuitions.
	www.uvm.edu /~phildept/?Page=pereboom/source7.htm (6250 words)

	An Essay on Free Will (Site not responding. Last check: 2007-11-02)
		lt;br /gt; lt;br /gt;Van Inwagen believes that the three arguments for incompatibilism that he presents are all good arguments (at least more reasonable than their denials) and, hence, by the end of chapter 3 he thinks he is justified in answering the compatibility question in the negative.
		The book begins by explaining the issues involved--the problems associated with fatalism, arguments for compatibilism, arguments for incompatibilism, the consequences of our not having free will, and the "traditional problem", which is mainly the question of whether or not we have free will.
		Van Inwagen examines and criticizes fatalistic claims, criticizes arguments for compatibilism, argues at length for incompatibilism, and claims that lack of free will is incompatible with moral responsibility, and that the belief in free will is psychologically necessary for deliberation.
	www.entertainment-reviews.com /An_Essay_on_Free_Will_0198249241.html (1256 words)

	620pixeltable
		It is against the idea that determinism is logically consistent with free will and moral responsibility, and also against the idea, as turns out to be possible to be, that these things are logically inconsistent.
		Determinism as True, Compatibilism and Incompatibilism as Both False, and the Real Problem".
		It is that each of the long-running traditions, Compatibilism and Incompatibilism, is false.
	www.eou.edu /~jjohnson/Determinism.htm (6121 words)

	dfwVariousHonderichAfter
		The doctrines of Compatibilism and Incompatibilism are both false, and demonstrably so.
		It is indeed a second assumption of this rapid paper, then, that both Incompatibilism and Compatibilism are false.
		'Compatibilism is the thesis that determinism is consistent with the claim that persons often have moral freedom or freewill.
	www.ucl.ac.uk /~uctytho/dfwVariousHonderichAfter.html (6623 words)

	Moral Responsibility
		This general trend of linking the consequentialist conception of moral responsibility with compatibilism about causal determinism and moral responsibility and the merit-based conception with incompatibilism continued to persist through the first half of the twentieth century.
		That is, unlike most former consequentialist forms of compatibilism, it helps to explain why we feel that some agents deserve our censure or merit our praise.
		It is likely that Strawson and others writing on moral responsibility have traditionally seen themselves as attempting to articulate an account of responsible agency that would map onto what was presumed to be a unitary and shared concept of moral responsibility.
	plato.stanford.edu /entries/moral-responsibility (5360 words)

Try your search on: Qwika (all wikis)