Factbites
 Where results make sense
About us   |   Why use us?   |   Reviews   |   PR   |   Contact us  

Topic: Darkness in El Dorado


Related Topics

In the News (Thu 31 Dec 09)

  
 Darkness in El Dorado - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Darkness in El Dorado (subtitled: How Scientists and Journalists Devastated the Amazon) is a controversial book published by the investigative journalist Patrick Tierney in 2000.
The title refers both to the story of El Dorado (an account of an indigenous civilisation encountered in roughly the same geographic area by the earliest European explorers) and to the novel Heart of Darkness by Joseph Conrad.
The book became controversial because of the accusations of improper, unethical and criminal conduct which it levelled against the anthropologist Napoleon Chagnon and the, then recently deceased, geneticist James Neel.
en.wikipedia.org /wiki/Darkness_in_El_Dorado   (291 words)

  
 Napoleon Chagnon Responds to Darkness in El Dorado by Patrick Tierney
"Although Darkness in El Dorado gives the appearance of being well researched, in many instances the author's conclusions are either contradicted or not supported by the references he cites," Alberts said.
Darkness in El Dorado calls attention to the dire plight of the Yanomami and other indigenous people of the Amazon and has caused anthropologists to reflect deeply upon the ways in which they conduct research.
The American Anthropological Association’s investigation of the charges in Darkness in El Dorado (Tierney 2000) found that the late James Neel and Napoleon Chagnon harmed the Yanomami in the course of their research in Venezuela and Brazil, and that Chagnon had violated the ethics code of the association.
www.anth.ucsb.edu /chagnon.html   (776 words)

  
 Public Anthropology
The first recorded AAA response [to Patrick Tierney’s Darkness in El Dorado], entitled “Statement on Allegations Made in the Book Darkness in El Dorado” reads in part: “The American Anthropological Association is aware of the publication of the book Darkness in El Dorado by Patrick Tierney.
Darkness in El Dorado has served anthropology well in that it has opened a space for reflection about what we do and our relationships with those among whom we are privileged to study” (AAA 2002:I.9).
It seems that despite the efforts of the [El Dorado] Task Force to seriously address accusations against Neel and Chagnon in its final report, the preface prefers to dismiss Tierney’s accusations and affirm nice-sounding abstractions that obscure the deeper issues that need to be addressed.
www.publicanthropology.org /PA/SurveyStatement3.htm   (1468 words)

  
 Science Show - 16 June 2001  - Darkness in El Dorado
'Darkness in El Dorado' is an account of the plight of the Yanomami people and the effects on them of contact with the American anthropologist Napoleon Chagnon.
"Darkness in El Dorado" gives the reader no opportunities to develop an affinity with the culture or the people affected, and so robs the argument of the power it needs to really make a different.
A large proportion of "Darkness in El Dorado" concerns the scientific practices of the American anthropologist Napoleon Chagnon whose fame arose from his studies of the Yanomami.
www.abc.com.au /rn/scienceshow/stories/2001/313371.htm   (1459 words)

  
 Psychology Today: DARKNESS IN EL DORADO (Book Review)
Darkness in El Dorado chronicles the devastation and death of perhapsthousands of Venezuelan Yanomami Indians, two careers, and any pretense of scientific objectivity.
Anyone reading Darkness in El Dorado must come away asking, "Is this any way to do research?" The book raises disturbing questions about how social science research is--or should be--conducted, and the obligations of researchers who work with the few remaining isolated populations.
Darkness in El Dorado is not an easy read: Its many side paths make it like walking into an Amazonian swamp; Yanomami personal and place names are long and (to English-speaking minds) difficult; the information Tierney presents is voluminous and sometimes tedious.
www.psychologytoday.com /articles/pto-20010301-000048.html   (570 words)

  
 Darkness in El Dorado: How Scientists and Journalists Devastated the Amazon by W. W. Norton & Company
As a layman I cannot comment on the soundness of the allegations in the book, though at face value they present a riveting indictment on the fact that 500 years after Columbus the clash between imported and local mores and cultures is as sad as ever.
Chagnon, however, has been dogged by criticism and controversy for years, and with the publication of Patrick Tierney's Darkness in El Dorado, the debate has erupted, forcing what may be the most tragic and shameful chapter of anthropological history into public view.
Darkness in El Dorado is an explosive account of how ruthless journalists, self-serving anthropologists, and obsessed scientists placed one of the Amazon basin's oldest tribes on the cusp of extinction.
www.hudson-river-fishing.com /us/0393049221.html   (1229 words)

  
 darkness in el dorado summary: essaysspot.com- the essay spot, the term paper spot, the research paper spot
On essaysspot.com there are hundreds of free essay abstracts written by your fellow college students on darkness in el dorado summary.
All of the essay abstracts on darkness in el dorado summary can be instantly downloaded from essaysspot.com.
Our professionals essaysspot.com here can write darkness in el dorado summary essay papers, ordarkness in el dorado summaryessay reports or any other essay subject to meet any deadline.
www.essaysspot.com /term-papers/188941/darkness-in-el-dorado-summary.html   (390 words)

  
 [No title]   (Site not responding. Last check: 2007-10-11)
The organizational structure of the book, Darkness in El’Dorado: How Scientists and Journalists Devastated the Amazon consists of the categorization of maps of Venezuela, graphs, a few consist of the Bisaasi-teri Mortality, The Measles Epidemic, Febrile Response to Edmonston B, and Victims in Worst Yanomamo Wars.
In many ways Darkness in El’Dorado has raised as many questions about Tierney’s motives, and those of Chagnon’s other critics, as it does about Chagnon’s own work.
Darkness in El’Dorado raises crucial questions about anthropological methodology, in general, and Chagnon’s work in particular.
people.clarkson.edu /~haynesmj/DarknessinEl_Dorado.doc   (1394 words)

  
 Kenan Malik's review of 'Darkness in El Dorado' by Patrick Tierney
In July 2002, the 'El Dorado Task Force' of the American Anthropological Association published its final report.
Darkness in El Dorado relies entirely on circumstantial evidence, hearsay, much of it from dubious sources, and questionable interpretations of film of Neel and Chagnon at work.
There is little doubt that Neel was a eugenicist who believed that modern society's problems arose 'primarily from abandoning the population structure and the selective pressures under which humankind evolved.' Humans originally evolved in small, relatively isolated tribal groups in which men competed with one another for access to women.
www.kenanmalik.com /reviews/tierney_darkness.html   (2660 words)

  
 Metroactive Books | Patrick Tierney; Napoleon A. Chagnon; Bruce Albert and Davi Kapenawa Yanomami
But Darkness in El Dorado, and the firestorm that has engulfed it, also raises troubling questions about investigative journalism, the incendiary nature of communicating via email, and the construction and consumption of knowledge in the age of the Internet.
This nightmarish story--a real anthropological heart of darkness beyond the imagining of even a Josef [sic] Conrad (though not, perhaps, a Josef Mengele)--will be seen (rightly in our view) by the public, as well as most anthropologists, as putting the whole discipline on trial.
What has elevated Darkness in El Dorado into a worldwide cause célèbre is a single chapter in Tierney's book titled "Outbreak," which chronicles a measles epidemic among the Yanomami in early 1968.
www.metroactive.com /papers/metro/02.22.01/cover/lq1-0108.html   (3172 words)

  
 darkness in el dorado: essaysking.com - the best source for free essays, free research essays, college essays
On essaysking.com there are hundreds of free essay abstracts written by your fellow college students on darkness in el dorado.
All of the essay abstracts on darkness in el dorado can be instantly downloaded from essaysking.com.
If you can’t find the right free essay on darkness in el dorado, we will be happy to provide you with a custom essay that you need.
www.essaysking.com /term-papers/188939/darkness-in-el-dorado.html   (431 words)

  
 New Statesman - A rumble in the jungle. A journalistic expose, which is unlikely to be published here because of our ...
A journalistic expose, which is unlikely to be published here because of our restrictive libel laws, has caused a sensation in the US with its allegations of genocide in the Amazon and academic subterfuge.
Darkness in El Dorado relies entirely on circumstantial evidence, hearsay and questionable interpretations of film of Neel and Chagnon at work.
Darkness in El Dorado raises important questions about anthropological methodology in general and Chagnon's work in particular.
www.newstatesman.com /200012180042   (2776 words)

  
 A Shadow Over the Amazon / Did a UC Santa Barbara anthropologist's research destroy the indigenous culture he studied?
They were naked and sweaty, green tobacco lodged in their lips, dark green mucus dripping from their nostrils.
Now, decades later, with the recent publication of "Darkness in El Dorado" by Patrick Tierney, accusations are flying that Chagnon was actually the dangerous one, and that the Yanomami might have been better off if they'd fired those arrows.
Though "Darkness in El Dorado" was a finalist for the 2000 National Book Award, it isn't something to pick up for the joy of reading.
www.sfgate.com /cgi-bin/article.cgi?file=/chronicle/archive/2000/12/03/RV116654.DTL&type=printable   (835 words)

  
 Darkness in El Dorado - Encyclopedia, History, Geography and Biography
Darkness in El Dorado - Encyclopedia, History, Geography and Biography
The book became controversial on account of the accusations of improper, unethical and criminal conduct which it levelled against the anthropologist Napoleon Chagnon and the, then recently deceased, geneticist James Neel.
Darkness in El Dorado, External links and 2000 books.
www.arikah.com /encyclopedia/Darkness_in_El_Dorado   (310 words)

  
 yanomami
El NacionalVersión: Violeta Linares Fuente: Revista The New Yorker
El comité se ha planteado una investigación a gran escala, bajo la conducción de expertos en medicina, especialistas en tribus nativas de América Latina, así como miembros del comité de ética y de derechos humanos de la asociación Americana por el Avance de la Ciencia, para darle mayor fuerza a la investigación.
El principal alegato en contra de Chagnon y Neel presentado en el libro de Tierney, aparenta ser deliberadamente fraudulento.
www.geocities.com /fotosmoramon/yanomami/yanomami.html   (1285 words)

  
 Napoleon Chagnon - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
In 2000, journalist Patrick Tierney published a controversial book titled Darkness in El Dorado, which included interviews that called into question the ethics of significant aspects of Chagnon's field work (as well as Asch's work) and questioned the accuracy of his publications based on that work.
Most of the allegations made in Darkness in El Dorado were publicly refuted by the Provost's office of the University of Michigan in November 2000 [1].
The American Anthropological Association convened a task force in February 2001 to investigate some of the allegations made in Tierney's book.
en.wikipedia.org /wiki/Napoleon_Chagnon   (321 words)

  
 Science in Question in Darkness in El Dorado - Freedom Magazine - Is there a Solution to the Prison Problem?
The first edition of Darkness in El Dorado, published in 2000, sparked a controversy, particularly among scientists whose methods in dealing with the Yanomami in South America it had criticized.
Their systematic abuse is the subject of Patrick Tierney’s memorable Darkness in El Dorado.
Tierney, a visiting scholar at the University of Pittsburgh who spent 11 years researching and writing Darkness in El Dorado, traces the Yanomami experiments back to the Manhattan Project, the effort directed by the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers which, beginning in 1942, produced the atom bomb.
www.freedommag.org /English/vol33i1/page14.htm   (746 words)

  
 Powell's Books - Darkness in El Dorado: How Scientists and Journalists Devastated the Amazon by Patrick Tierney
He demonstrates how these researchers, as well as journalists and scientists, echoed the travails of the Spanish and English explorers of five centuries ago as they sought the illusory city of El Dorado, a promised land already destroyed by their own brutality.
In painstaking detail, Tierney explores the hypocrisy, distortions, and humanitarian crimes committed in the name of research, and reveals how the Yanomami's internecine warfare was, in fact, triggered by the repeated visits of outsiders who went looking for a "fierce" people whose existence lay primarily in the imagination of the West.
Copiously annotated and well documented, the work is the culmination of a decade-long study of what Tierney claims is false science; along the way, he exposes the dark side of some famous social-biologists....
www.powells.com /cgi-bin/biblio?inkey=1-0393049221-3   (687 words)

  
 darkness in el dorado essay free: essaysoutlet.com- the essays outlet, term papers outlet, book reports outlet, ...
essaysoutlet.com is a website that has a wealth of free essay abstracts on darkness in el dorado essay free.
essaysoutlet.com is the only reliable resource for quality essays on darkness in el dorado essay free.
If you feel that the abstract matches what you're looking for, you can download the darkness in el dorado essay free abstract directly from essaysoutlet.com.
www.essaysoutlet.com /cat/paper/320/darkness-in-el-dorado-essay-free.html   (378 words)

  
 Untitled Document
Tierney spent eleven years researching and writing Darkness in El Dorado.
To understand the media storm surrounding Darkness in El Dorado, readers should take note of how Tierney's publisher publicized it.
Darkness in El Dorado is a brilliant work of investigation that chronicles the history of Western exploitation of the Yanomami Indians." And a CNN.com "Book News" report, dated October 2, 2000, notes, the "publisher W. Norton.
www.publicanthropology.org /AAAReferendum/ElDoradoTaskForce05March/BackgroundControversy5.htm   (973 words)

  
 The Chronicle: Daily news: 12/03/2001 -- 03
Since the "El Dorado Task Force Preliminary Report" was published on the association's Web site, just before Thanksgiving, both defenders and critics of the scholars named in the book by the journalist Patrick Tierney have faulted the report for mistakes and omissions.
In response, the association appointed a committee, the El Dorado Task Force, to investigate Mr.
Several of the most visible partisans from last year's debate over Darkness in El Dorado were in the audience but chose not to speak publicly.
chronicle.com /free/2001/12/2001120303n.htm   (1634 words)

  
 Pittsburgh author's charges stir up anthropologists
Even before an excerpt of the Pittsburgh author's book, "Darkness in El Dorado," was published in the Oct. 9 issue of The New Yorker, anthropologists were in an uproar about its allegations.
In his book "Darkness in El Dorado," Patrick Tierney claims anthropologist Napoleon Chagnon caused murderous behavior in the South American Indians and geneticist James Neel carelessly or callously introduced measles to the tribe.
Now that "Darkness in El Dorado" is about to be released, Tierney's publishers are letting him respond to his many critics.
www.post-gazette.com /magazine/20001115tierney2.asp   (2048 words)

  
 The AAA's Initial Response to the Accusations
This was a way for the AAA to change the topic away from the bigger allegations Tierney made in is book Darkness in El Dorado, according to which Chagnon had committed “a serious violation of Yanomami human rights and our Code of Ethics” (Borofsky 2005:46).
The task was “to examine assertions and allegations contained in Darkness in El Dorado as well as others related to the controversy” (Borofsky 2005:47).
The purpose of the El Dorado Task Force was to “gather information in a fair and open manner and will carefully consider evidence that either substantiates Tierney‘s allegations or casts doubt on them” (Borofsky 2005:48).
students.washington.edu /cooljo/aaaresponse.html   (570 words)

  
 Home Page
Perhaps one of the most important questions raised by this controversy is the question of whom the study of anthropology is supposed to benefit and to what extent are certain people exploited for the benefit of others.
Ever since Patrick Tierney published his book "Darkness in El Dorado," there has been a noticeable change in the way anthropologists think and act in their research.
Despite the ethical issues arising from Darkness in El Dorado, the Yanomami controversy does not speak to the issues that matter the most.
students.washington.edu /shand/Pics/Impact.shtml   (440 words)

  
 comparison chagnon darkness dorado: termpapersdoctor.com- term papers doctor, research papers doctor, essays doctor
Overall, the ugliness in twentieth century literature tends to move away from darkness in the environment and move towards showing the real darkness apparent in life, the darkness of human suffering.
This darkness occurs as a means of forcing people to question both themselves and the society they live in.
Looking for a term paper on "comparison chagnon darkness dorado?" termpapersdoctor.com can help you find a free term paper abstract on "comparison chagnon darkness dorado." termpapersdoctor.com can provide you with 3123 free abstracts from term paper written by the best students on your subject.
www.termpapersdoctor.com /term-papers/158299/comparison-chagnon-darkness-dorado.html   (426 words)

  
 Darkness in El Dorado by Patrick Tierney
Patrick Tierney's book Darkness in El Dorado, published on November 16, is in bookstores now.
Darkness in El Dorado raises essential questions about research involving human subjects.
Newsweek examines the controversy, November 27, 2000: "In 'Darkness in El Dorado: How Scientists and Journalists Devastated the Amazon,' writer Patrick Tierney describes more than three decades of encounters between researchers, filmmakers and reporters, on the one hand, and the 24,000 Yanomami hanging on in the rain forest of Brazil and Venezuela.
www.wwnorton.com /trade/external/tierney   (1534 words)

Try your search on: Qwika (all wikis)

Factbites
  About us   |   Why use us?   |   Reviews   |   Press   |   Contact us  
Copyright © 2005-2007 www.factbites.com Usage implies agreement with terms.