| |
| | Language Log: Professional Foolishness |
 | | A favorite activity here on Language Log is pointing out the deficiencies of what various non-specialists say and think about language and linguistics: journalists (here, here, and here), language pundits (here, here and here), geneticists, political scientists, actors, and sea captains. |
 | | Even the "lumpers" distinguish half-a-dozen language families in New Guinea; historical linguists who insist that relationships be established by the comparative method divide the non-Austronesian languages of New Guinea into 68 language families. |
 | | There is a proposal by Joseph Greenberg for a language family known as Indo-Pacific, consisting of the Papuan languages, the languages of Tasmania, and the languages of the Andaman Islands, but it has never been supported by adequate evidence and is not taken seriously. |
| itre.cis.upenn.edu /~myl/languagelog/archives/000780.html (1081 words) |
|