| | Glorfindels Galore | Lord of the Rings Fanatics Library (Site not responding. Last check: 2007-10-19) |
 | | The Glorfindel of Gondolin also really must be Noldorin, for he was highly important figure in the Noldorin city of Gondolin (though there were many Sindar in Gondolin, it doesn't seem likely that one would have achieved Glorfindel's status, and actually, Gondolin was initially said to have been almost entirely Noldorin). |
 | | The intitial reason given by Tolkien is that Glorfindel, as seen in his sacrifice, had a deep love for the Elves of Middle-earth, and a desire to continue to aid them to the point of his death and beyond. |
 | | Combined with this complaint is the idea that Tolkien did not mention Glorfindel's reincarnation until over 15 years after The Lord of the Rings was written; therefore, it seems evident that he did not intend for the two Glorfindels to be the same while writing the saga. |
| www.lotrlibrary.com /agesofarda/taleoftwo.asp (2190 words) |