| |
| | Dr Pahilan vs COMELEC et al : 142970 : June 20, 2000 : Atty. Villarama : En Banc |
 | | The present controversy stemmed from a petition for exclusion of election returns in Precincts 8A, 8A-1, 9A, 9A-1, 1A, 1A-1, filed by petitioner before the Municipal Board of Canvassers of Guinsiliban, Camiguin which the latter denied on the ground that petitioner’s allegations of vote-buying and misappreciation of votes were not proper grounds for pre-proclamation controversy. |
 | | Meanwhile, during the pendency of petitioners’ appeal at the Commission on Elections (Second Division), the Board of Canvassers proceeded with the proclamation of Henio N. Abecia as the mayor of Guinsiliban, Camiguin. |
 | | Consequently, the Second Division of the Commission on Elections resolved to exclude the returns of the subject precincts from the canvass of elections returns, declared the proclamation of private respondent null and void and directed public respondent Board to reconvene and recanvass the remaining or uncontested returns and proclaim the winning candidate. |
| www.supremecourt.gov.ph /resolutions/enbanc/2000/EJun/142970.htm (631 words) |
|