| | Re: Hines relies too much on Seaver, methinks |
 | | Looking at the text, we can discern a geographical sequence in Adam's numerical listing, so we can be fairly certain that King Svein was giving him a pretty accurate and logical account of the North Atlantic lands known to the Norse explorers, and that "Halagland" was the "Helluland" of the sagas. |
 | | As pointed out in the scholion (probably not written by Adam himself) the real Halagland/Helgeland is a part of the Norwegian mainland. |
 | | Most of Adam's information about Halagland, including the Midnight Sun, relates to the real Helgeland- and his "nearer to Norway" would seem to be an attempt to reconcile Svein's description of Helluland (not really Halagland), over the sea with the other description of Helgeland (aka Halagland), part of Norway. |
| www.talkaboutabook.com /group/alt.books.tom-clancy/messages/258322.html (629 words) |