| |
| | Hipparcos - the first space astrometry mission (Site not responding. Last check: 2007-10-07) |
 | | The 22 January 2004 Nature paper by Pan, Shao and Kulkarni, arguing that the Hipparcos data may be "contaminated by systematic errors on small angular scales", and that their results "reaffirms the fidelity of current stellar models", is a misleading contribution to a difficult and important problem. |
 | | The Hipparcos parallax for Atlas (HIP 17847), of 8.57+/-1.03 milliarcsec, is not mentioned by the authors, but is at roughly 1 sigma of the Pan et al result. |
 | | Instead, Pan et al focus on the comparison of their individual star with the Hipparcos mean distance to the cluster, and proceed to argue that the star is probably close to the cluster centre and therefore representative of the mean cluster distance (which may be so, but the authors have not demonstrated it). |
| www.rssd.esa.int /hipparcos/Pleiades_distance.html (631 words) |
|