| | Journeyman: The Two-Fold Magisterium (Site not responding. Last check: 2007-10-19) |
 | | I had thought of arguing for a three-fold Magisterium of hierarchy, theologians and faithful, noting that a church ruled by the masses will institutionalize pedestrian theology and worship, a church ruled by theologians will endlessly debate the arcane and the irrelevant, and a church ruled by the hierarchy will be distracted by power. |
 | | Sometimes it's also called “the Magisterium of the Moment.” While lip service may be paid to the authority of Scripture and Tradition, Scripture can't be an authority in the sola ecclesia church because the church interprets Scripture, and Tradition can't be an authority because the church interprets Tradition. |
 | | This is a far cry from sola ecclesia and the “Magisterium of the moment.” Dulles explicitly conditions the infallibility of the pope on (a) agreement with Scripture and Tradition, (b) agreement with the present faith of the church, (c) agreement with the universal episcopate, and (d) sufficient investigation. |
| crowhill.net /journeyman/Vol1No3/dulles.html (3578 words) |