Material implication - Factbites
 Factbites
 Where results make sense
About us   |   Why use us?   |   Reviews   |   PR   |   Contact us  

Topic: Material implication


    Note: these results are not from the primary (high quality) database.


In the News (Mon 16 Nov 09)

  
 Relevance logic - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Relevance logic aims to capture aspects of implication, or entailment, which are ignored by the "material implication" operator in classical truth-functional logic.
The fundamental novelty in relevance logic is to change the semantics of implication in such a way that the premises of a valid argument must be "related" to the conclusion.
Lewis was led to invent modal logic, and specifically strict implication, on the grounds that classical logic holds, for example, that a falsehood implies any proposition.
en.wikipedia.org /wiki/Relevant_logic   (435 words)

  
 Strict conditional - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Such a conditional would, for example, avoid the paradoxes of material implication.
However, the direct encoding of this formula in classical logic using material implication lead to:
In logic, a strict conditional is a material conditional that is acted upon by the necessity operator from modal logic.
en.wikipedia.org /wiki/Strict_conditional   (481 words)

  
 Entailment - Encyclopedia, History, Geography and Biography
In many cases, entailment corresponds to material implication: that is, A, X \models Y if and only if A \models X \to Y.
Implication or entailment is used in propositional logic and predicate logic to describe a relationship between two sentences or sets of sentences.
Ideally, semantic implication and logical implication would be equivalent.
www.arikah.com /encyclopedia/Entailment   (420 words)

  
 Material Implication
Material implication is not a precise formalization of the imprecise ordinary language term "implication".
Material implication (symbolized, for example, A --> B for "A implies B") was supposed to symbolize ordinary-language implication of the type "All crows are black" / "If it's a crow, it's black".
It really seems that material implication is just plain not usable as a formalization of a large class of real-world events, namely those having to deal with historical events.
www.idiocentrism.com /phil.implicate.htm   (1215 words)

  
 Material Implication
Material implication doesn’t give us the whole story about what we normally call implication, but it gives the common core that has to be present in any more developed account.
The first is that material implication – as you and many others have noted elsewhere – isn’t the same as what people are talking about in ordinary speech when they say that one thing is implied by another.
The second point is that no one is going to be misled by material implications such as the one from Castro’s being a dictator to the color of your pants.
personal.bgsu.edu /~roberth/m-imp.html   (973 words)

  
 Brief introduction to logic
Material implication asserts that if the premise of an argument is true, then we are required to assert that the conclusion is also true.
By definition of material implication, column 4 is true for every row of the truth table except for any row that has a true premise (column 1) with a false conclusion (column 3).
It should be noted that material implication in and of itself is blind to the propositions involved.
www.sirus.com /users/mjake/Brief.html   (7793 words)

  
 Implication -- Facts, Info, and Encyclopedia article
In (The branch of philosophy that analyzes inference) logic, material implication is a binary operator.
Also in (The branch of philosophy that analyzes inference) logic, semantic implication and logical implication describe possible relationships between two sets of statements.
In (The study of language use) pragmatics ((The scientific study of language) linguistics), (An accusation that brings into intimate and usually incriminating connection) implication has a different meaning.
www.absoluteastronomy.com /encyclopedia/i/im/implication.htm   (126 words)

  
 Conditional Statements and Material Implication
Material implication is the weakest common meaning for all types of "If … then …" statements.
Abstract: The reasons for the conventions of material implication are outlined, and the resulting truth table for is vindicated.
A Comparison of Techniques for Introducing Material Implication, a discussion of seven ways of introducing truth-functional definition of material implication by Matthew C. Clarke at the University of Natal.
philosophy.lander.edu /logic/conditional.html   (829 words)

  
 Peter Suber, "Paradoxes of Material Implication"
Material implication is just one of many sorts of implication, and for that reason does not conform exactly to the English "if...then" or "implies".
(3) For material implication, despite its perversity, suffices to capture the logically essential core of meaning in ordinary uses of implication.
And this sarcasm exactly follows the logic of material implication.
www.earlham.edu /~peters/courses/log/mat-imp.htm   (1192 words)

  
 Logical conditional -- Facts, Info, and Encyclopedia article
This particular conditional is called material implication or the material conditional, and is properly represented by the symbol ⊃ rather than the less specific symbol →.
One problem is that the material conditional allows implications to be true even when the antecedent and the consequent have no logical connection.
This table needn't be taken as "the definition of →", however, because its contents can also be derived from the axioms of the (A branch of symbolic logic dealing with propositions as units and with their combinations and the connectives that relate them) propositional calculus.
www.absoluteastronomy.com /encyclopedia/l/lo/logical_conditional.htm   (1197 words)

  
 Mind: Reply to Kovach - article by Adam Kovach in this issue, p. 575, on a deflationist account of truth
Material implication and truth are interdefinable, at least in the sense under which a definition provides a necessarily equivalent condition.
Horwich allows himself the resources of a material implication relations between propositions and a notion of broadly logical necessity that is not understood in terms of truth.(1) Yet all would be for naught, if Horwich's resources were not legitimately available to the deflationist.
So suppose the deflationist were denied appeal to material implication in formulating her theory and giving explanations.
www.findarticles.com /p/articles/mi_m2346/is_n423_v106/ai_19635812   (1314 words)

  
 Logic - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Closely related to questions arising from the paradoxes of implication comes the radical suggestion that logic ought to tolerate inconsistency.
Eliminating these classes of paradox led to David Lewis's formulation of strict implication, and to a more radically revisionist logics such as relevance logic and dialetheism.
It is easy to observe that the notion of implication formalised in classical logic does not comfortably translate into natural language by means of "if...
en.wikipedia.org /wiki/Logic   (3434 words)

  
 Lecture Notes: Strict Implication
Material implication "is obviously a relation between the truth-values of propositions, not between any supposed content or logical import of propositions."
To show that material implication is not a relation of content, meaning, intension, etc., Lewis brought forward a number of "peculiar theorems" of Russell's system.
The expression "material implication" was coined by Russell to refer to a special class of formulas in his logic, i.e., those of the form:
philosophy.ucdavis.edu /mattey/phi134/strict.htm   (1243 words)

  
 The Architecture of Teaching: Archive Entry From Brad DeLong's Webjournal
Zizka: Material implication is _the_ implication of mathematics.
Material implication is a artificial invention of the logicians, but it has the advantage that it makes possible a two-valued logic, where every sentence is either true or false.
Or to put it differently, the two values of material implication should be described as "invalid" (p.~q) and "not invalid" (rather than "valid")-- rather like "guilty" and "not guilty" in law (there is no "innocent" in law, as I understand).
www.j-bradford-delong.net /movable_type/2003_archives/002093.html   (5782 words)

  
 symbolic logic. The Columbia Encyclopedia, Sixth Edition. 2001-05
This kind of implication, in which the connection between the antecedent and the consequent is merely formal, is known as material implication.
The biconditional, or double implication, is the equivalence relation and is true only if the two statements have the same truth value, either true or false.
The conditional, or implication, corresponds to “if … then” or “implies” in ordinary language, but only in a weak sense.
www.bartleby.com /65/sy/symbolic.html   (732 words)

  
 Sophia on the web: Logic Page ~ Truth Tables
Material implication is represented by the hook (a U on its side and open to the left) or an arrow (pointing from P to Q)
MATERIAL EQUIVALENCE: P if and only if Q = "water if and only if H2O is present" (also called bi-conditional, in that they are both true or both false).
This material is rarely covered but some may find this as a nice challenge.
members.aol.com /moresophia/topic12.html   (1001 words)

  
 University of Dayton
The topics to be dealt with are as follows: deductive logic, arguments, validity, logical implication, material implication, information containment, tautology, contradiction, soundness, the method of form, introduction of symbols, statement logic, syllogism, truth tables, proofs, Venn diagrams, predicate logic, fallacies, inductive logic, cogency, arguments from authority, induction by enumeration.
Students are responsible for all announcements made or material covered in class.
Symbols will be dealt with to the extent necessary to acquaint students with logical structures of language, but the emphasis will be on the connection between logic and everyday language use.
academic.udayton.edu /RanjooHerr/logic.htm   (795 words)

  
 Matthew C. Clarke
The truth table for material implication can be shown to follow naturally from the subset relationship P[subset]Q which unambiguously disallows the situation where membership of P is true but membership of Q is false, and allows the other three possible situations.
Material implication is an attempt to capture the essence of conditional statements: that is (in English at least), statements of the form "if...
Most commonly, material implication is defined by truth table or some verbal equivalent such as "X-->Y is always true if X is false and also if Y is true" [HILB50 p4] or "A conditional sentence is false if the antecedent is true and the consequent is false; otherwise it is true" [SUPP57 p6].
www.cs.cornell.edu /Info/People/gries/symposium/clarke.htm   (3374 words)

  
 stult2.html
I drew her to the implication that, if that were the case, then the very language she used to articulate her position added to the problem.
The following material is VERY tentative at this point, was written several years ago, and lacks the rigor and precision that is in its future.
We can then proceed to draw the implications of this inability as a 'negatively demonstrated' absolute.
www.christian-thinktank.com /stult2.html   (4703 words)

  
 Kearns2.htm
Material implication can then be analyzed as involving a degenerate notion of ‘case’—one in which the only ‘case’ considered is the actual state of affairs.
The table shows that the material implication is only false when the antecedent is true and the consequent is false.
Either the logical system should be revised so these propositions are not equivalent or ordinary if should not be identified with material implication.
www.ku.edu /~pyersqr/Ling331/Kearns2.htm   (3432 words)

  
 Implication - Implication Quotes
Implication of the Pro12Ala polymorphism of the PPAR-gamma 2 gene in type 2 diabetes and obesity in the French population Maya Ghoussaini* 1, David Meyre*
This was the result of my implication that there would be a "surprise" in store for any who met her face to face.
Exploring the implication of the novel endolysosomal protein endoyln in neoplastic This implication has resulted in increasing number of proposed
www.listf.com /?q=implication   (155 words)

  
 A Note On Mr. De Morgan
It is important to note, however, that the same "usefulness" could exist for a negated material implication.
where the first equivalence is supported by material implication, the second equivalence is supported by De Morgan’s Rule (!), and the third equivalence by multiple negation.
Material equivalence means merely that, when the material equivalence is true, the propositions have the same truth values.
www.apa.udel.edu /apa/archive/newsletters/v96n2/teaching/morgan.asp   (1593 words)

  
 implication --  Britannica Concise Encyclopedia - The online encyclopedia you can trust!
In most systems of formal logic, a broader relationship called material implication is employed, which is read “If A, then B,” and is denoted by AB or AB.
This conception of implication is based upon the meanings of the propositions, not merely upon their truth or falsity.
The biological implications of the element and its simple compounds have been discussed earlier; the most significant implications are associated with organic compounds, which are discussed in such articles as chemical compound.
www.britannica.com /ebc/article-9042218   (1003 words)

  
 Re: Implication
We now have four concepts of implication or consequence in hand: material implication, strict implication, the interpretational account of logical implication and the substitutional account of logical implication.
A sentence S materially implies a sentence S' just in case the corresponding material conditional S -> S' is true, in other words just in case either S is false or S' is true.
It is clear that ' 'snow is white' is true' materially implies 'snow is white', and vice versa, because they are both true.
www.philo.at /phlo/200001/msg00069.html   (1939 words)

  
 r35.htm
Strict implication is either formal or material; that is, either the argument’s form or the meaning of its terms makes it impossible for the argument to have true premisses and a false conclusion.
The same point applies to material implication (in the sense of the implication relation between the premisses and conclusion of a materially valid argument), as well as to probabilistic implication, as can be shown by counterexamples.
Probabilistic implication is a relation in which it is improbable that the premisses are true and the conclusion false; in at least some cases, this probabilification is a function of the argument’s form, as in induction by enumeration.
www.trentu.ca /ossa/r35.htm   (4250 words)

  
 Speakers Guide
Implication: Allow more time for learners to process new unrelated material or material that conflicts with their current knowledge.
Implication: It is imperative that teachers plan and organize their material.
They prefer materials be presented through the use of more than one medium; they prefer to control the pace, start and stop time.
www.physiatry.org /annual/speakersguide.htm   (2832 words)

  
 Implication Encyclopedia Article, Definition, History, Biography
In logic, material implication is a binary operator.
Also in logic, semantic implication and logical implication describe possible relationships between two sets of statements.
In medical diagnosis and in forensics or scientific investigation of a condition, a hypothetical cause is implicated when a reason for the condition can be found, given that cause.
www.karr.net /search/encyclopedia/Implication   (265 words)

  
 Guilt by Association: On Iffy Propositions and the Proper Treatment of Mental-Models Theory
That a material implication is true when the antecedent is false is a matter of textual fact in propositional calculus, but it is not what is considered to be the case in human reasoning.
We show that the presumed evidence against material implication is not inconsistent with mental-models theory and that neither the conjunction hypothesis nor the conditional-probability hypothesis conflicts with a proper treatment of mental-models theory (i.e., Johnson-Laird and Byrne, 2002).
In the following we will however expose the sophistry in the presumed implications of this finding for mental-models theory, which rests on misconceptions about the material-implication hypothesis and/ in mental-models theory.
cpl.revues.org /document411.html   (4027 words)

  
 Mind: Deflationism and the derivation game - response to Matthew McGraw, Mind, vol. 106, p. 69, 1997
In the first place, material implication, and entailment are relations between propositions that are typically explained in terms of truth.
Until there is some indication of how the facts about entailment and material implication are to be explained without appeal to truth, inflationists are right to insist that deflationists are not entitled to such premises for explaining facts about truth.
Another way to interpret (PMI) is as indicating an infinite list of axioms, individual implication principles, such as "If the proposition that snow is white is true materially implies the proposition that snow is white, then if it is true that snow is white, then snow is white".
www.findarticles.com /p/articles/mi_m2346/is_n423_v106/ai_19635811   (1451 words)

  
 Relevance Logic
Since the truth of the consequent of a relevant implication is by itself insufficient for the truth of that implication, things can have properties irrelevantly as well as relevantly.
On these interpretations, what is needed for an implication to be true is that the antecedent carry the information that the consequent obtains.
By itself, the ternary relation is not sufficient to avoid all the paradoxes of implication.
setis.library.usyd.edu.au /stanford/entries/logic-relevance   (2533 words)

Try your search on: Qwika (all wikis)

Factbites
  About us   |   Why use us?   |   Reviews   |   Press   |   Contact us  
Copyright © 2005-2007 www.factbites.com Usage implies agreement with terms.