| |
| | MnM |
 | | But Quine’s point is that ordinary systems of definitions normally contain at least one term which is antecedently and nontechnically understood, in which case the circularity (of course) does not matter, while among the family-circle words there is no such term--they are all technical. |
 | | Stipulatives are metalinguistic, besides being hortatory or proclamatory in mood, while (in terms of truth conditions) the corresponding object-language trivialities are directly about the world, however little they illuminate it. |
 | | Even when philosophers construct elaborate systems of stipulative definitions, our interest is not in the definitions themselves, which can have no nontrivial consequences, but rather in the way in which the system connects up to the real world, and the latter cannot be stipulative. |
| www.unc.edu /~ujanel/MnM.htm (8672 words) |
|