| |
| | Journal of Seventeenth-Century Music | Vol. 6 No. 2 | Review (Site not responding. Last check: 2007-10-21) |
 | | The consequences lead to an elimination of the violone, because it, “as a transposing instrument” (Bonta, “From Violone”, 75), is considered unsuitable for eight-foot functions. |
 | | This is a problem that anyone dealing with ancient instruments must face, time and again, whenever the researcher is confronted either by illustrations of ancient instruments or by the instruments themselves. |
 | | Unless one can resurrect the maker of each instrument, or a contemporary who played it, and ask him what name he had in mind as he made it or played it, to name each as Planyavsky does is a reckless exercise in wishful thinking that no trained scholar would ever be guilty of. |
| sscm-jscm.press.uiuc.edu /jscm/v6/no2/Bonta.html (2278 words) |
|