| |
| | Underwater: This is Not a Film: Pitchfork Review (Site not responding. Last check: 2007-11-06) |
 | | Underwater mostly shun sentimental pap, but inevitably pop music leads to pop sentiment ("At night I feel inbetween.../ Always, I never know what i need.../ Always"). |
 | | It's not that Underwater shouldn't be allowed sweet moments; it's just that this leaves the listener unprepared for the eight-minute static hum of "I'll Say Your Name." Likewise, "Silver" opens like a Portishead jam outtake, until chorus lines intrude. |
 | | Underwater has sidestepped pretension to create an album for cloudy days and rainy nights, filled with all those classic, bereaved emotions: longing, regret, blame, trust, betrayal. |
| www.pitchforkmedia.com /record-reviews/u/underwater/this-is-not-a-film.shtml (584 words) |
|