| |
| | Weblog Entry - 2001 Jun 05: "The Return of the King: BOOK V - Chapter 5" |
 | | Again, in a later draft of the Ride of Rohirrim, the Woses appear as "the dark men of Eilenach (which later became Druadan Forest)" In that version, it is a force of Woses and Treebeard, with the Ents!, that attack the Orcs guarding the roads north of Minas Tirth while the Riders race on. |
 | | I have read LOTR countless times, and have never felt the Woses to be an extraneous element, or been bothered by a lack of proper "set-up." I would think their appearance would have far less impact if it were preceded by some corny "there's something in the woods" statement. |
 | | I react to the Woses as "hey, where did those guys come from?" The Pukelmen are there beforehand, yes, and Merry gets an explanation, but I always felt they were a bit out of place in the story, and their short appearance not really up to Tolkiens storytelling standards. |
| www.electricpenguin.com /blatherings/lotr/archives/00000051.html (7322 words) |
|